Would We Accept "Single Payer" Groceries? |
|
|
|
| Daily Dose of Reason - Health Care Reform | ||||
| Monday, 06 April 2009 00:00 | ||||
Does "universal coverage" for medical care mean that any coverage is good, and that all coverage is created equal? If so, then why isn't it this way with other things? Why isn't it this way with cell phones, televisions, automobiles, computers, and groceries? In all of these areas, you have objectively better and worse products. In all of these areas, you have more or less equally good products that inspire different preferences in people. Imagine the grocery store with only ONE brand of spaghetti sauce, ONE type of cereal, ONE size and quality of ketchup, and ONE type of bread. On top of it, imagine all of these selected by a government agency and imposed on the population by Congress. I can't imagine Americans ever tolerating this in groceries--or anything else, for that matter. Yet with health care, it's somehow different. With health care, most of us cannot wait to turn the whole thing over to government. We don't want to buy it. We don't want to shop for it. We don't want to make our OWN judgments about which treatments and procedures seem necessary, or a good deal (in consultation with a doctor, of course). Most of us think somebody else should PAY for it. And many of us think someone else should make all these decisions for us, too. Even if it's the same kind of people who brought us the post office, the department of motor vehicles and the IRS?
|
||||
Special Feature
Featured
Shopping
Books & Booklets Audio Commentaries, Interviews & Advice Articles & Essays Coaching/Therapy Newsletter Newsletter Back Issues MerchandiseOther
Shopper and Email login
Shopping Cart
Your Cart is currently empty.
Wait for the payment page to appear after your order is confirmed. If you haven't entered your payment information, your order will not be completed. When ordering instant downloads, your shipping and credit card billing addresses must match. Problems? Call 302-539-5986 or contact Dr. Hurd.
DR. HURD'S NEW BOOK!
Click here to purchase your autographed copy!(Choose domestic or International delivery. Price includes shipping.)
Daily Dose Mug
Get your official Daily Dose Coffee Mug! Click "merchandise" in the shopping menu to the left. Psychotherapy
Want to address an issue head on in a peaceful, oceanside location? Come to the beaches of Delaware for our special Reflection...by the Sea package.Stop and Think...
" By striving to do the impossible, man has always achieved what is possible. Those who have cautiously done no more than they believed possible have never taken a single step forward. "Mikhail Bakunin
Recent News
- Respect: The key to romance
- Good or Bad Economy, for Obama It's a Win-Win
- A Divided America? If Only!
- The Grand Illusion of Medicare
- Making Peace With Bullies Never Ends Well
- Peter, Paul, Barack and Mitt
- "It's Not Fair!! Why Me?"
- The Psychology of Sexual Abuse
- Rehab: An empty promise?
- Free Will: The Engine of Mental Health



Does "universal coverage" for medical care mean that any coverage is good, and that all coverage is created equal? If so, then why isn't it this way with other things? Why isn't it this way with cell phones, televisions, automobiles, computers, and groceries? In all of these areas, you have objectively better and worse products. In all of these areas, you have more or less equally good products that inspire different preferences in people. Imagine the grocery store with only ONE brand of spaghetti sauce, ONE type of cereal, ONE size and quality of ketchup, and ONE type of bread. On top of it, imagine all of these selected by a government agency and imposed on the population by Congress. I can't imagine Americans ever tolerating this in groceries--or anything else, for that matter. Yet with health care, it's somehow different. With health care, most of us cannot wait to turn the whole thing over to government. We don't want to buy it. We don't want to shop for it. We don't want to make our OWN judgments about which treatments and procedures seem necessary, or a good deal (in consultation with a doctor, of course). Most of us think somebody else should PAY for it. And many of us think someone else should make all these decisions for us, too. Even if it's the same kind of people who brought us the post office, the department of motor vehicles and the IRS?
